Skip to content
←Back to glossaryCyber

Legacy authentication

Sign-in protocols that carry only a username and a password (IMAP, POP, authenticated SMTP, NTLM) and cannot ask for a second factor, which makes them a way around MFA.

Definition

Legacy authentication covers the sign-in protocols that carry only a username and a password and cannot ask for a second factor. In email that means IMAP, POP, authenticated SMTP and the older modes of Exchange ActiveSync; on the directory side, NTLM and applications that bind with simple LDAP. The flaw is built in: MFA (multi-factor authentication) turned on for the account does not apply when the session goes through one of them. Password spraying, a handful of common passwords tried against thousands of accounts, goes straight for these entry points. The attacker gets into a mailbox without ever seeing an MFA prompt, and wire fraud starts from there. Microsoft began switching off basic authentication in Exchange Online on October 1, 2022, after several delays. The issue did not go away with it. On-premises Exchange servers are still around, as are business apps that send mail over authenticated SMTP, multifunction copiers and directories still running NTLM. In the logs, what keeps these protocols open is usually some forgotten piece of equipment: a copier, a UPS sending its alerts, an old billing script. The cyber questionnaire asks two ways: head-on (is legacy authentication blocked?) and indirectly, when it asks whether MFA covers all access to email. A "yes" to the second with legacy protocols left open is a wrong answer, even given in good faith. The evidence sits in the conditional access policy that blocks legacy clients, or in sign-in logs filtered by client type. Underwriters increasingly ask for that screenshot instead of a ticked box.

Its 7 cross-references, woven across the glossary's 18 categories
Legacy authentication: Cyber glossary illustration, AlgoPolis
Example

Textbook case, made-up figures: an 80-person accounting firm ticks "MFA on all email". The sign-in log provided at the underwriter's request shows, over thirty days, 4,200 successful IMAP sign-ins from a billing package and two copiers, and 1,900 failed authenticated SMTP attempts from foreign addresses. The underwriter draws a plain conclusion: the declared MFA does not protect those connections. The underwriter asks for the planned cut-off date and reclassifies the question as a partial answer.

Read next
Put it to work
Related terms
Also known as

legacy auth, basic authentication, basic auth, legacy authentication protocols

Stay informed

Follow the research

One letter a week. First, the week's underwriting note, when one is published: a dated, argued decision, signed by Paul Bernardski. Then what the observatory published on cyber risk, political risk and insurance. No account, no tracking.

No spam, one-click unsubscribe, no data ever sold.