Buy-back clause after recovery
A fine art policy clause that lets the insured, when a stolen and indemnified work is found, buy it back from the insurer that now owns it by repaying the indemnity, sometimes indexed, within a set period.
A painting insured for 1 million euros at agreed value is stolen in 2018; the insurer pays a total loss, and the release transfers title to the work to the insurer. In 2024, police find it in a storage unit. Who gets it? With no clause, the insurer, which sells it and keeps the proceeds. The buy-back clause after recovery gives the insured an option: take the work back by repaying the indemnity received. Wordings differ on three points the claims adjuster reads before anything else. The price first, the nominal indemnity, or the indemnity indexed to an annual rate or a price index, sometimes plus the recovery and restoration costs the insurer has incurred. The deadline next, often a few weeks from notice of recovery; after that the insurer can dispose of the work freely. Then what happens to any gain: some policies share the proceeds of a resale above the indemnity. The option matters most when the market for the artist has risen between the theft and the find, since the insured buys back at yesterday's price an item worth more today; when prices have fallen, he leaves the work with the insurer. For the underwriter, the clause weighs little on expected cost, since most stolen works never come back, but it counts in the negotiation with a collector attached to one specific piece. Then there is the matter of condition: a work recovered damaged is bought back at a price the appraisal has to adjust, and the wording rarely provides for it. Not to be confused with subrogation, by which the insurer that has paid takes over the insured's claims against the thief or the liable party, without saying anything about who owns the recovered item.
Textbook case: the painting stolen in 2018 was indemnified at 1,000,000 euros. Found six years later, it is valued at 1,800,000 euros. The clause provides for a buy-back at the indemnity indexed at 2 percent a year, within sixty days of notice. Buy-back price: 1,000,000 × 1.02 to the power of 6, about 1,126,162 euros. An insured who exercises the option takes back a 1,800,000 euro work for that price. If he lets the deadline pass, the insurer sells, and the proceeds above 1,000,000 euros stay with it, unless a sharing clause applies.
buy-back clause, recovery clause fine art, repurchase of recovered artwork, recovered property clause
Follow the research
One letter a week. First, the week's underwriting note, when one is published: a dated, argued decision, signed by Paul Bernardski. Then what the observatory published on cyber risk, political risk and insurance. No account, no tracking.
No spam, one-click unsubscribe, no data ever sold.